Needs more seeding options
The one thing that prevents me from using Challonge only as my main bracket program is the lack of seeding options. There is no way to seed people by location which is what most people are concerned about in brackets since people from the same location should be equally separated in the bracket. There is no way to only seed a set number of players. Instead if you do that it will put everyone in order from 1 to whatever number of players are in the tournament. There is no way of combining seeding methods i.e. skill and location. These are things that really need to be added to Challonge. Give us a way to seed players by location. Give us the ability to seed a set number of players. Give us the ability to seed players and separate the rest by location. All of this would make Challonge the absolute best bracket program. There are some programs that allow you to do these things already however they are stand alone programs and don't have full online integration like Challonge does. People want to be able go online and keep updated on tourney results as they happen. Add the additional seeding options with that and Challonge then becomes without a doubt #1, that is unless they aren't added and some of these other programs end up going fully online.
สนใจ พาเพลิน commented
It is an online gambling website that has the most members. Because it is a gambling website that has been trusted by a large number of people, there are many service users and there is also a fast service that makes users with us impressed and trusting us.123สล็อต
azan imran commented
Ver Coreanas, Chinos, Tailandia, Japones, Estrenos Doramas And Movies con Subtítulos en Español
Want to get your program assignments done the right way? We can give you access to some of the best programming assignment help out there - Call us today for a shortcut to success in your academic goals.
Ashwini Sharma commented
Custom Antibody Market
Automated Parking System Market
Smart Transportation Market
Collagen and Gelatin Market
Smart Appliances Market
Anti Inflammatory Drugs Market
Fire Protection System Market
word wipe commented
These are the things that Challonge truly needs to go with. provide the option to seed a specific number of participants and a method for seeding players based on their location. Thank for sharing. https://wordwipe.io
Debra Lee commented
I recently discovered Challonge and immediately assumed it was the solution to my online bracket hosting dreams. Unfortunately, more manual modification of the seeding settings is required. Our state tournament provides the host league a first-round bye, then sends the losers of Games 3 and 4 to the Loser Bracket (13 teams), whereas Challonge sends the losers of Games 2 and 3 to the Loser Bracket (13 teams). That would normally be acceptable, but because so many tournaments have minor quirks like this, Challonge isn't quite right yet. I believe that allowing users to drag-and-drop seeds wherever, followed by setting which lost games move to the first L-bracket, will provide the desired flexibility. I'm disappointed that Challonge will not be available for our DE 13-team tournament. It appears to be a fantastic site, however it isn't nearly flexible enough. Continue to improve. I look forward to using your services in the future! https://drift-boss.io
John Mick commented
Click https://www.saadashraf.net/ to get web design & development services.
watch all spanish daramas here in HD quality ·<a href="http://doramasvip.me/">pandrama</a>
Andrew oliver commented
Are you a student who is feeling overburdened by your online classes? You are not alone, believe us. Students nowadays, whether online or on-campus, are always grappling with their academics. There has been an increase in online schooling as a result of the continuing coronavirus epidemic. Students, on the other hand, are dealing with a slew of issues and have no one to turn to.
We have exactly the same problem. We want to use challonge to live-document sports events who use some other scheems of seeding. The winner bracket can be manually rearranged. However the Losers/Hope Bracket is fixed.
However I propose a more general scheme:
Add the feature to challonge to generally define the seedings in brackets (an "external" numbering of players and matches), not as a default but as an OPTION. This would just need an intermediate absract layer and ANYTHING can be achieved.
Seeding is also a big issue for me.
However I think it has to be adressed in general to enable all kinds of neccessities.
So maybe it can be pre-organized somehow for the developers to draw their conclusions.
A) we should differ between static seeding and dynamic seeding.
- with static seeding I mean there is only the first draw: all matches and ways are set.
- "dynamic seeding": after each round, or elimination round there can/will be a new drawing. This can again depend on certain criteria, such as divide (put them on the most distant branches) the strongest players or players which are locally more close or distant. With this you can try to "enforce" stronger endgames and reduce the risk that weak players end in endgames by lucky draws. (if you want that)
B) RULES and Criteria to seed.
B1) Initial static seed and dynamic seeds
I think it will be hard or impossible to provide "all/any" criteria. Maybe it will be a start to consider each player/team with "attributes". Ideally a "real" value. I think without restricting generality we could call this "strenght". The seeding algorithm can then have the option (or multiple options) to put the most strongest players as distant as possible. And that for every round with a new draw, depending of who wins and looses. (Something like the chess ELO-number) could be a critera. Other criteras could be "vicinity" of players. You probably do not want to have players of one team fight against each other in the beginning, but allow them all/both to reach the final.
B2) double elimination. Also here modified seeds for the loosers round would be a valuable addition.
B3) The "strenght" number could change during the game. (such as the premention ELO number). even if all players at the beginning will start with the same value, the performance of the guys in the "loosers" round could "rankup" or "rankdown" the "strength" number in the winnersround. This can help to put the stronger guys on more distant branches and avoid the strong clashes in the early rounds and spare them for true finals. It also would help to equilibrate the chances in the loosers round.
I just discovered Challonge and quickly thought this was the answer to my online bracket hosting hopes. Alas the seeding options need to allow more manual customization. Our state tournament gives the host league a first round bye, and then sends loser of Games 3 and 4 to the Loser Bracket (13 teams) whereas Challonge forces loser of G2 & G3 to go. Normally that'd be fine, but so many tournaments have minor quirks like this, Challonge doesn't quite fit yet. I think if (1) you allow users to drag-and-drop seeds anywhere, and then (2) set which losing games go to the first L-bracket, that would provide the flexibility needed. I'm really disappointed we won't be able to use Challonge for our DE 13-team bracket. I really looks like a great site, but is not quite flexible enough. Keep improving. Hope to use your service in the future!
In my current situation I would like to be able to add participants and re-arrange their seeding without having to re-enter all of the names again. For example, if I have entered 10 participants and then a new entry with a high level of skill comes in, I would like to add them to the participant list with a high seed. I am just trying this out for the first time, but I was not able to manually arrange the seeding after input. (I know that I can drag names around the brackets after, but that just causes mayhem).
I would like to be able to rearrange or re-draw the bracket between say, round 1 and 2 of a 32 participant single elimination tournament, similar to what happens in the UEFA Europa League.
Justin Arroyo commented
i agree, i dont like having to manually seed by location and try to keep the top competitors on top. to much bracket theory. this would make Challonge the best bracket system in the world.
Thanks for sharing this suggestion! We totally agree, so it's a matter of prioritizing this. We're pretty tight on resources and time, so more votes or comments here will definitely help keep this on our radar.
I went searching through all of the posts hoping to find this. This is EXACTLY what's holding most of the smash community backing from going completely to Challonge.com. I personally love Challonge, but it's seeding options are so limited.
Please Challonge, this x1000!
Any thoughts on this?